Many of Carleton’s visiting speakers are leaders in fields that intersect directly with civic engagement. Carleton students have a rich opportunity to make vital connections between these speakers’ insights, civic engagement coursework and collaborations, and their own lives. We at the CCCE want to support the extraordinary work students, faculty, and other Carleton community members are doing to facilitate these connections, and in that spirit we offer these discussion questions around the work of visiting community-engaged speakers.
Faculty: Please let us know if you have any suggestions for future discussion questions!
Students and Community Members: If you are interested in more reflection questions for past and future community-engaged visiting speakers, let us know!
Jim McCorkell ’90 (February 24, 2023)
Jim McCorkell ‘90 is the founder and former CEO of College Possible, a national nonprofit organization making college admission and success possible for low-income students through an intensive curriculum of coaching and support. He currently consults with a variety of clients, with an emphasis on helping social entrepreneurs create, grow and scale their efforts.
As CEO at College Possible, Jim was responsible for leading strategic organizational development, engaging and building relationships with national partners, and championing the organization’s commitment to creating more college graduates. Over his 20 year tenure, the organization grew from a start-up in his spare bedroom into a national organization operating in seven American cities, reaching 25,000 low-income students, with an annual budget of $30 million. Under Jim’s leadership, the organization helped 98% of its students earn admission to college, and he helped raise nearly $150 million.
Jim is a graduate of Carleton College and Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government. His work has been recognized with many awards, including the Ashoka Fellowship, alumni achievement awards from Carleton and Harvard, and the Executive Leadership Award of Excellence from the Nation College Attainment Network. He has served on many boards over the years, and now serves with Reading Partners Twin Cities.
Since leaving College Possible, Jim focuses on sharing his hard-earned wisdom by coaching and developing leaders through his consulting practice, Excelerate Consulting, as well as teaching, and serving on nonprofit boards.
He lives in St. Paul, MN with his wife, Dr. Christine Greenhow, their son Jack, and their golden retrievers, Milly and Maddy.
- Jim McCorkell was a low-income, first-generation student at Carleton. In an interview with Minnesota Public Radio, McCorkell talked about Carleton being his introduction to “a life I hadn’t really been exposed to before.” In what ways was coming to Carleton an adjustment for you? How did your family structure, lived experience, and social identities impact your transition to Carleton?
- Professor Paul Wellstone was an important mentor for McCorkell at Carleton. Wellstone used to say: “Leadership is calling on people to be their own best selves.” How can you call on people to be their own best selves? What can you do to bring out the best in others in any setting?
- In an article for Higher Learning Advocates, McCorkell cites a statistic from a Strada-Gallup poll, saying that, “a mentor who encourages a student’s goals and dreams is the single most important factor in whether a college graduate finds success in work and in life.” What role have mentors played in your high school and/or college experiences so far?
- McCorkell says that College Possible is about “paying it forward.” He was able to get where he is because of his mentors, and he wants other low-income students to have access to mentorship as well. Who has helped you get where you are? Consider ways you could “pay it forward” in your future endeavors. How might that align with your Carleton or post-Carleton plans and goals?
- What did you learn about how McCorkell’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does McCorkell suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities? What can you do to learn those skills?
- What is the desired future that McCorkell envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Christy S. Coleman (February 10, 2023)
Christy S. Coleman has served as the Chief Executive Officer of some of the nation’s most prominent museums. She’s a tireless advocate for the power of museums, narrative correction, diversity and inclusiveness. Ms. Coleman is an innovator and leader in the museum field having held leadership roles at the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, the Charles H. Wright Museum of African American History, and the American Civil War Museum. She now serves as the Executive Director of the Jamestown-Yorktown Foundation.
Ms. Coleman is the recipient of numerous awards for her decades of impact, including three Honorary Doctorates. In 2018, Time Magazine named her one of the 31 People Changing the South and in 2019, Worth Magazine named her one of 29 Women Changing the World. She’s written numerous articles, is an accomplished screenwriter, public speaker and has appeared on several national news and history programs.
She served as the historical consultant for the award-winning film Harriett and Showtime’s Good Lord Bird. She’s most recently appeared in award winning documentaries, Grant, Abraham Lincoln, Black Patriots: Civil War Heroes, Neutral Ground, and When The Monuments Came Down.
- In a talk about intentional museums given at Harvard’s Peabody Museum of Archeologuy & Ethnology, Coleman said: “History has never been for the dead, it has always been about the living. Our extensive knowledge and increasing knowledge about what we understand about the past has been brought about because of the questions that we are asking of ourselves in the present. We are looking for grounding. We’re looking for connection. We are still looking to belong.”
How has history influenced your lived experiences?
- In the same talk as the quote above, Coleman reflected on community-engaged scholarship and the role of academic institutions such as museums within communities:“We have to really be listening to our communities and provide them what they want versus this is what we think you need.”
If you have done community-engaged coursework or scholarship at Carleton or in the past, what was that experience like? What does it look like to listen to what a community needs? What are the challenges and rewards of doing ethical community-engaged scholarship?
- Christy Coleman’s website displays the following quote: “We’ll never get right with each other until we get our shared history right.” What does this quote mean to you? What does it mean to get history “right”?
- What did you learn about how Coleman’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Coleman suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities? What can you do to learn those skills?
- What is the desired future that Coleman envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Dr. Gregory Pence (January 20, 2023)
- Pence’s textbook “Medical Ethics: Accounts of Ground-Breaking Cases” is considered a fixture in the field of medical ethics. Where does knowledge about the ethics of community and civic engagement come from? How might these sources compare and contrast with those of medical ethics?
- Pence’s textbook “Medical Ethics: Accounts of Ground-Breaking Cases” has been published since 1990. In the book, Pence follows up on famous cases 5, 10, and 20 years later. What could be the benefits and challenges of this approach in medical ethics? Could this approach be applied to the ethics of community engagement? What could be some benefits and challenges in that context?
- In an interview about his new book Pandemic Bioethics, Pence said he believes that “everyone who lived through the COVID-19 pandemic has been changed fundamentally.”
- Has living through the COVID-19 pandemic changed how you approach civic engagement work?
- What has changed or stayed the same through the COVID-19 pandemic with your civic engagement work?
- Pence explains that “With every bioethical issue I write about, I try to present it in historical context, whether it’s allocating organs to recipients or AIDS.” How do you interact with historical context in your civic engagement work?
- The Early Medical School Acceptance Program at University of Alabama at Birmingham, of which Pence is director, describes its goals: “While classroom success is crucial, it’s important that EMSAP students develop skills for independent thought and expression, emotional maturity, and sound moral judgment.” Is there anything you would add to this list? What skills would you consider “important” for students participating in civic engagement?
- What did you learn about how the speaker’s individual life experience contributed to their academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does the speaker suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that the speaker envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Julian Brave Noisecat (October 21, 2022)
- Noisecat notes that within modern ways of thinking, there is a large separation between humans and the world humans live in. This separation, Noisecat argues, leads to exploitation and extraction from nature. What can we do to merge the two entities into a holistic way of knowing?
- In an interview with the Post Carbon Institute, Noisecat highlights art and creativity as reasons for hope as the world enters into an era of environmental catastrophe. How does art and creativity positively impact your community?
- Noisecat states in an interview with CNBC that, beyond addressing climate change, “We also need to figure out how to have a more reciprocal and just relationship with the resources and the natural world that sustain us.” What are ways that you can have a more just and reciprocal relationship with the natural world?
- In an interview with France 24, Noisecat describes indigenous people as being “post-apocalyptic people” who have important wisdom and leadership skills as the modern world faces apocalyptic challenges. In times of crisis, who do you look to for guidance?
- In an interview, Noisecat’s mother, Alex Roddy, describes Noisecat’s early fascination with indigenous history, particularly a TV series called 500 Nations. Roddy believes that the series was an important part of how Noisecat came to understand his indigenous identity. What materials and relationships have helped you understand your identities?
- Noisecat notably facilitated an event remembering the 50th anniversary of the occupation of Alcatraz by sailing eighteen canoes representing different indigenous groups across San Francisco Bay. What anniversaries are important in your community? When you celebrate them, what are you remembering?
- What did you learn about how Noisecat’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Noisecat suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Noisecat envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Jose Antonio Vargas (October 14, 2022)
- Define America, a culture change organization, was founded in 2011 by Vargas and professionals from the media in order to bring attention to the stories of immigration in America. This sparked a debate on what it really means to be “American”. What connects us to a nation? What does it mean to be a part of a community? What are some similarities and differences between belonging to a nation and belonging to a community?
- Define America advocates for undocumented immigrants by sharing stories, starting campaigns, and engaging young people in the issues. How can we advocate for people who are not in positions of power and do not have access to resources (such as government programs for people who are undocumented)? What does support look like? Thinking about positionality, how can we use our resources to better aid our community?
- In his essay, My Life as an Undocumented Immigrant, Vargas recounts the fear involved in living without legal documentation. Even though he had “lived the American Dream”, he rarely trusted people enough to disclose his identity as an undocumented person. How can we build trust within our community? What does that look like?
- Vargas produced a documentary called “White People”, in which he discusses “what it means to be young and white in a demographically-changing America”. This documentary was praised for the ways Vargas facilitated the conversation in a non-threatening way. Rice county is 80.2% white (not Hispanic or Latino) with a relatively large Hispanic population of 9% and a Black and African American population of 6.6% according to the 2021 census. What do productive discussions on ethnic demographics and issues look like? How can we create a space where it feels safe to talk about issues relating to race? How does a mosaic of ethnicities create a community?
- Despite the praise given to Vargas’ documentary, it was criticized for promoting “white guilt”, the belief that white people have a collective responsibility for the harm done to racial minorities in the past and present. How do we talk about power structures pertaining to race without inflicting “white guilt”? Is it something that we need to avoid? Is it on the facilitators, like Vargas and other BIPOC creators to manage this feeling? Do we see “white guilt” as something constructive or destructive in talks about race?
- What skills or capacities does Vargas suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Vargas envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Alexandra Barba ’09 (October 7, 2022)
- In this interview with Brown University, where she earned her Masters of Public Affairs, Alex Barba describes the skills she uses in her work as Director of Strategy & Chief of Staff for Colorado Outbreak Response Coordination: “There is great value in hard skills — understanding data and data visualization, for example, is invaluable in governmental policy — but what has proved most useful in this role is my ability to work with groups, to quickly read and summarize a policy paper, to give an effective presentation.” Which skills are valuable to your civic engagement work? Do the “most useful” skills change from day to day?
- In an interview with Brown University, Barba says her current position “is expanding my range, challenging me in new and different ways every day, and putting me in contact with the higher-ups in the world of Colorado policy.” Do you feel challenged by civic engagement? How so? Who does it put you in contact with?
- Barba talks about her experience participating in three OCS programs at Carleton: I learned about cultures and people living completely different lives from myself or anyone I’d ever known … and learned a great deal about my own capacities and limitations.” What are the similarities and differences between Barba’s experiences studying abroad and your experiences conducting civic engagement work in Rice County? What are some limitations you have run into?
- On her LinkedIn profile, Barba describes herself as a “cross-functional professional with a proven background in team & project management, policy analysis, political science research, and literary editing.” How would you define a “cross-functional professional”? Are students conducting civic engagement work “cross-functional”?
- According to her LinkedIn profile Barba is a ProsciⓇ Certified Change Practitioner. Prosci offers a Change Management Certification Program, which they describe as an “engaging, interactive, three-day learning experience” that gives participants “the knowledge, skills and tools to drive successful change.” Outside of professional training programs, how else might one acquire the knowledge, skills and tools needed to facilitate change? Is there an advantage to having an official certification on your resume?
- Barba is quoted in a February 2021 article about Colorado’s COVID-19 vaccine hotline, which was “experiencing extreme wait times.” She explains that “we are addressing every single customer and question they have to the best of our ability” What role does individual connection play in your civic engagement work? Have you encountered any challenges that the best of your ability can’t resolve? What resources and tools do you use in those situations?
- What did you learn about how Barba’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Barba suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities? Are there any you would like to incorporate into your work or daily living?
- What is the desired future that Barba envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Aimee Nezhukumatathil (September 30, 2022)
Born to a Filipino mother and Malayali Indian father, Aimee Nezhukumatathil (neh-ZOO / koo-mah / tah-TILL) is the author of four books of poetry: Oceanic (Copper Canyon 2018), Lucky Fish (2011), winner of the Hoffer Grand Prize for Prose and Independent Books; At the Drive-In Volcano (2007); and Miracle Fruit (2003), all from Tupelo Press. Her collection of nature essays, World of Wonders: In Praise of Fireflies, Whale Sharks, and Other Astonishments, was published by Milkweed in 2020. With Ross Gay, she co-authored Lace & Pyrite, a chapbook of nature poems (Organic Weapon Arts, 2014). Aimee Nezhukumatathil is also known for her dynamic and joy-filled teaching. Equally at ease in a university or high school classroom, she often serves as a poetry “ambassador,” bringing the delights and joys of reading and writing poetry to classrooms all over the country. She has twice served as a faculty member for the Kundiman Asian American Writers’ Retreat. Her books are widely adopted for high schools, colleges, and universities as part of contemporary poetry, women’s studies, and Asian-American literature classes. She has been a featured reader at over a hundred venues across the globe from Amsterdam to Singapore. In 2014, Nezhukumatathil became one of the country’s youngest poets to achieve the rank of full Professor of English. During the 2016-17 academic year, Nezhukumatathil was the John and Renee Grisham Writer-in-Residence at The University of Mississippi. She is now professor of English and teaches environmental literature and poetry writing in the MFA program of the University of Mississippi.
- In an interview with fellow poet and professor Ross Gay, Aimee Nezhukumatathil was asked about the importance of wonder. She said:
“Look around us—just about every hurt we see in the news is caused by a person’s lack of imagination, a lack of curiosity about their fellow human beings, a lack of wonder. How could I not want to set the groundwork for my sons so they grow to be curious adults who let themselves be filled with awe, unapologetically. How could I not wish to celebrate and cultivate wonder now?”
Who are the people in your life who have shown you what a sense of wonder looks like?
Can you think of times in your life when hurt was caused by a lack of curiosity or wonder?
- In an interview with NPR, when asked if she ever loses that sense of wonder, Nezhukumatathil responded:
“Every day. Every day, and then double that during a pandemic. My hope is that it’s a practice. As with anything, it’s a practice, it’s work.”
When have you felt as though you were losing your sense of wonder? What do you do to practice your sense of wonder? What activities, places, plants, animals, or people make you feel wonder?
- Much of Nezhukumatathil’s writing draws from her experiences living as an Asian American in the United States. She describes nature as a refuge where she didn’t need to explain herself or her family. Nezhukumatathil also writes about the lack of representation of people of color, specifically Asia Americans, in the outdoors.
How do your identities shape the ways you interact with the natural world? Is the outdoors a place you feel comfortable? What feelings and memories does the outdoors bring up for you, and are those feelings and memories related to your identities?
- Nezhukumatathil’s writing blends scientific language and natural history facts with stunning imagery and emotional storytelling. In an interview with Melissa Sevigny, Nezhukumatathil says her “not-so-dirty secret” is that she reads more science and natural history books than she does literature.
Do you feel more comfortable writing and thinking in one discipline (Biology, English, Philosophy, Geology, etc.) than in another? Are there ways that these disciplines intersect at Carleton? What aspects of different disciplines resonate with you and why?
Cathy Yandell (September 23, 2022)
Carleton French professor Cathy Yandell will deliver the 2022 A&I convo on September 23.
- Some of Cathy Yandell’s work “addresses the question of “learning through the body” or
Renaissance ways of understanding the world through bodily images, references, and
paradigms”. (source) Can you think of ways that people “learn through the body” today?
- What “ways of knowing” or types of knowledge do you think are most valued at Carleton?
Why? What other “ways of knowing” can you think of? How have you experienced these
different ways of knowing? What is the value of learning in different ways and from different
Mona Chalabi (May 13, 2022)
Questions for Mona Chalabi: “Taking the Numb Out of Numbers”
Mona Chalabi is a journalist who really loves numbers. She is the Data Editor of The Guardian where she writes articles, produces documentaries, and illustrates and animates data. After analyzing statistics for the United Nations, Chalabi saw how important data was, but also how easily it could be used by people with their own specific agendas. Since then, her work for organizations like Transparency International and The Guardian has had one goal: to make sure as many people as possible can find and question the data they need to make informed decisions about their lives.
With an inimitable visual style that strays far from cold and clinical graphs and charts, Chalabi has built a career highlighting neglected information through her striking data illustrations.
- Chalabi states that her goal is “to make sure as many people as possible can find and question the data they need to make informed decisions about their lives.” How have you used data to navigate your life and engage with your community?
- After analyzing statistics for the United Nations, Chalabi saw “how important data was, but also how easily it could be used by people with their own specific agendas.” Why is it easy for people to appropriate data for their own agendas? What are some strategies that can help us see through them? When we use data, how can we make sure we are not appropriating it for our own agendas?
- In this article, anthropologist Sally Engle Merry outlines the pitfalls of large-scale indicator-based quantification, especially for social justice work and global governance. What is so “seductive” about numbers?
- Chalabi’s work in data journalism ranges from updating Du Bois’ data on racism to investigating the correlation of recession and sex, to hypothesizing the demographics of heaven. How do you think about ‘breadth vs. depth’ of one’s work? In what ways can working on and thinking about various topics and issues deepen/lessen our understanding and appreciation of particular topics?
- How does Chalabi’s background and personal experiences (example) impact the way she thinks about civic engagement and inform the way she engages in her local, national and global communities? How do you think your background and experience influences the way you think about your engagement with communities?
- What skills or capacities does Chalabi suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you have those skills or capacities? Is it something you want to develop?
- What is the future that Chalabi envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Phil Chan ’06 (May 6, 2022)
Questions for Phil Chan ’06, AAPI Month Convocation
- The vision of the Final Bow for Yellowface, an organization co-founded by Phil Chan, underscores the effects of outdated and offensive stereotypes of Asians in ballet, “If all audiences see is the bobbing and shuffling coolie from a bygone era as the only representation of Asians on stage, what message does that send to our Asian students who dream of dancing the Swan Queen? What does that say to the Asian audience members who want to see themselves on stage, only to find themselves as the butt of the joke? What does that say to the Board member, who writes checks and involves their friends, only to see a one-dimensional representation of their heritage?” Why do you think it is important to take into account the stakes of different groups in a particular issue? What are some challenges you have encountered in engaging variously positioned groups with a cause and what are some strategies to overcome them?
- In an article about the restaging of a ballet pantomime called the Ballet des Porcelaines (also known as The Teapot Prince) by Chan and his collaborators, Chan says “It was fun to work within the constraints of what it actually was originally… The ‘rules of the game’ were that I had to use what the libretto says matching with the music. But how, then, could I bend the work outside of those rules? How could I interpret the libretto in a slightly different way for a contemporary audience?” Which “rules of the game” have you interacted with in the context of a specific initiative or issue you have engaged with? How do social, political, and economic systems shape these interactions?
- In the same article as in the previous question, Chan adds, “Reboots, remakes, reimaginings are important, but also looking at the larger ecosystem, we need to make space, especially for artists of color, to tell new stories.” What do you think are some opportunities and limitations of “reboots, remakes, and reimaginings” within an existing system? Reflecting on your positionality regarding a specific initiative or issue you delve into, how do you navigate these opportunities and limitations?
- The introduction to the “What’s the Tea?” series that Chan co-created in conjunction with AAPI month in 2020 opens with the line, “As Asians in dance, our experiences with race can sometimes feel invisible. Perhaps this is because we are often already in the room (if not fully at the table), therefore our experiences can be discounted.” How does this understanding of diversity, equity, and inclusivity align with or challenge your view? What are some ways to engage meaningfully with the nuances of power relations to move towards a more just future?
- What did you learn about how Chan’s individual life experience contributed to his engagement in social change work, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Chan suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Chan envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Andrew Morrison (April 15, 2022)
As those who made it to Convocation may already know, Andrew Morrison is a Carleton alum, class of ‘82, and “development economist passionately committed to social inclusion” with over twenty years of experience with the world’s leading development banks. Currently, he works and lives in Lima, Peru and is a visiting professor teaching Gender, Race and Ethnicity in Latin American Economic Development this term. Andy has generously given us some time this afternoon to have a more engaged conversation about his work. This event is a part of the SEXploration event series that the CCCE’s Health and Belonging cohort is putting on this month in collaboration with other campus offices. Although sexual health and wellbeing are the main themes of the event series and there is a raffle for prizes from Smitten Kitten (see the sign in sheet), Andy will be talking with us today about his expertise in gender equality policies from an economist’s perspective and how behavioral science works to end intimate partner violence.
Questions for Andrew Morrison ‘82
- The report Applying Behavioral Insights to Intimate Partner Violence: Improving Services for Survivors in Latin America and the Caribbean “leverages insights from the behavioral sciences, including behavioral economics, social psychology and neuroscience, to provide recommendations to improve the design of survivor services in the LAC region and, ultimately, to lead to better life outcomes for women” (page 5) Carleton’s liberal arts encourages students to form multidisciplinary approaches: what impact(s) does drawing from such diverse fields have? In your opinion, does it provide a more comprehensive approach to violence prevention?
- One of the objectives of the Applying Behavioral Insights report is to “encourage policymakers in LAC to test new approaches to improving IPV survivor services in a policy area where evidence of successful interventions is scarce (page 9).” How has the report been received since its publication? Why is this policy area scarce in evidence of successful interventions?
- In a couple of pieces of your work you mention its parameters: the report does not “seek to identify and address all barriers that hamper effective access and use of services by IPV survivors” and recognizes “that there are challenges for which, given the nature of root causes, behavioral interventions do not provide an effective solution” (page 10) and in an IDAB blog post you mention that “development banks should work on gender equality in their areas of comparative advantage.” Why do you think it is important to recognize the boundaries of one’s work as an individual, member of a field, or part of an institution? Are there situations where such recognition could result in drawbacks? How do you navigate these different outcomes?
- The Anti-Racist Teaching Collective defines positionality as: “‘the notion that personal values, views, and location in time and space influence how one understands the world. In this context, gender, race, class, and other aspects of identities are indicators of social and spatial positions and are not fixed, given qualities. Positions act on the knowledge a person has about things, both material and abstract. Consequently, knowledge is the product of a specific position that reflects particular places and spaces.’” How do you see your positionality and identities as involved in your work? Have they provided you with any unique insights? Any barriers?
- How has the COVID-19 pandemic affected your work? Has it opened any doors?
- Regarding your work with “new masculinities to engage men as allies,” is there a dimension of vision involved in this work? What tenets guide your thinking of the future?
- You mentioned some of your work lies in “access to financial services and the provision of integrated services to empower women.” Do you consider these as two separate objectives (financial services and integrated services)? Why or why not?
David Cole Wheeler (April 4, 2022)
- Wheeler emphasizes “how important it is to have a strong community that takes care of one another and is able to be open and honest in order to create positive change.” In what ways do you feel that the communities you belong to are caring, open and honest? In what ways do/can you contribute to building such a community?
- The mission of Ben’s Lighthouse, of which Wheeler is a board member, states that it strives to “empower children and teens to develop the self-awareness, empathy and social connections they need to find and share their own light.” Reflect on your upbringing. Do you feel that fostering these qualities in children are valued in your communities? What are some opportunities and barriers for young people in your communities to develop these qualities?
- In this speech, Wheeler calls gun violence “a problem so multifaceted, so enormous, and so pervasive that nothing less than change in our culture and our society can begin to address this.” Recall the ways in which Wheeler suggests we tackle gun violence and how he himself engages in the community to make change. Reflect on large-scale issues that you care deeply about. How do you ensure you do your part in enacting systemic change? How do you keep yourself motivated and committed in the face of problems that seem so vast and given that change can often be imperceptible in the short term?
- How do your background and personal experiences impact the way you think about civic engagement and inform the way you engage in your communities?
- What skills or capacities does Wheeler suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the future that Wheeler envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Alix Freedman (February 18, 2022)
- Freedman’s convocation is titled “The Power of Facts in an Opinionated World.” How are “facts” defined in the context of shared knowledge and community engagement? Could what is considered a “fact” be dependent on cultural perspective? What strategies could help reconcile the differences between these perspectives, if any?
- Freedman has “spent much of her decorated career as a reporter, with a keen focus on topics that require unusual reporting skill, courage, and dedication.” What practices or habits does engaging with the community require or encourage? How are they similar or different from those employed by journalism?
- Freedman described her process in writing “Population Bomb”, published 1998: “‘Ýou don’t need to sacrifice ambiguity, contradictions and denials to get where you are going.”’ What could be some strategies for handling contradiction in a collective story and collective organization? Is there a place for ambiguity in civic engagement?
- In this interview, Freedman describes the role of a newspaper: “‘A newspaper has many missions […] We want to change the world sometimes, and sometimes we just want to tell a good story.” What are your “missions” in participating in civic engagement? Are they distinct from one another or overlapping? Do your missions ever create bias or create conflicts of interest in your work?
- Freedman discusses the process of making and correcting mistakes in journalism in this 2017 podcast: saying “when we make mistakes, and we sometimes do, we are going to correct them fast and fully.” What are the roles of humility, open-mindedness, and taking responsibility in journalism? What about civic engagement? Do they share any similarities in the two contexts?
- This Principal’s Guide post defines the relevance of scholastic journalism and community engagement: “relevance means students will create localized coverage that informs and empowers audiences to participate in their communities.” Do you agree with this definition? Could your work be described in this way?
- Freedman, in this podcast, says that in journalism, “speed is a virtue, but haste is a vice.” Does this statement apply in civic engagement? How do we know when we have an adequate understanding of the community and its issues, how do we know when to act without being paralyzed by the desire to understand the situation better, and how do we know when to stop and revise our action? What happens if we act too quickly or too late?
- What did you learn about how Freedman’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Freedman suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Freedman envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Danielle Feinberg (February 11, 2022)
Danielle Feinberg is a cinematographer and director of photography for lighting at Pixar Animation Studios. She delivered a convocation on February 11, 2022.
- Feinberg has worked on a lot of notable Pixar projects, from A Bug’s Life to Coco. But she also helps out with groups that empower and uplift girls in STEM, such as Girls Who Code. Have you ever used your knowledge of another field to solve a problem? How can you relate your skills you use everyday to your community based work?
- Outside of her professional work, she acts as a mentor for girls to increase interest in STEM. What makes a good mentor? How can you apply your specialized knowledge to the community you serve?
- Fienberg agrees to go to every talk offered to her, to provide a platform to encourage girls to pursue their dreams in STEM. What is your platform? What are you encouraging in your community and why? How can these goals and information be expressed in an accessible way to our community?
- What did you learn about how the speaker’s individual life experience contributed to their academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does the speaker suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that the speaker envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Toni Carter (February 4, 2022)
Toni Carter ‘75 serves on the Board of Commissioners for Ramsey County and is scheduled to deliver a convocation address entitled, “Creating Healthy Communities” on Friday February 4, 2022.
- In your opinion, what defines a healthy community? How does your civic engagement work fit into this vision?
- Carter worked “as a teacher at Crosswinds Middle School, IBM systems engineer, marketing representative and systems support manager, and communications and arts consultant” as well as acted professionally before being elected to the Ramsey County Board of Commissioners. What professional roles and life experiences do you draw upon in your work in civic engagement? What transferable skills have you developed from these experiences?
- Carter serves as co-chair of the Ramsey County Juvenile Detention Alternatives Initiative and Deep End Reform program. This program has a Stakeholders Committee, Steering Committee, Leadership Team and Alternatives Governance Committee. Have you encountered similar organizational structures in your civic engagement work? What might be some reasons for this type of structure, with multiple committees and subcommittees composed of members of different backgrounds, focusing on various topics? What are some effects of such a structure?
- In her announcement to not seek reelection as County Commissioner, Carter cited dat on declining youth incarceration rates and unprecedented housing supports as “‘indicators of our countywide focus on equity and inclusion, and of our work to apply community-engaged, data-driven equity lens across all county systems.”’ What are some benefits and drawbacks of using a “data-driven” lens? What kind of lenses do you bring to your community engagement work?
- Carter initially ran for county office in 2005 after seeing “how Ramsey County’s services could complement the school system’s efforts.” How are your efforts in civic engagement complemented by those of others? How do they support other efforts?
- Julie Ring, Executive Director of the Association of Minnesota Counties, describes Carter: “We have a limited number of county commissioners of color and so those folks get called on a lot to try to bring their perspective into our work [….] where we have pockets of refugees or immigrants and commissioners are still learning about those new communities. Toni has been so willing to be engaged with those folks as they’re working to understand the changing demographic […] She’s had to serve as a representative all by herself for a while.” How can we ensure this process of learning and representation is mutually beneficial? Have you ever felt that you were the single representative of a group?
- In a Carleton Voice feature, Carter defines politics as “the process of gaining support for work that will achieve positive ends for people in my community.” Do you agree? If not, how would you define politics? What words would you use to describe this process?
- What did you learn about how Carter’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Carter suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Carter envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Valarie Gonzalez (January 28, 2022)
Valerie Gonzalez, an investigative reporter based in Pharr, Texas, is scheduled to deliver a convocation address on Friday January 28, 2022.
- The convocation introduction states that Gonzalez “works to bring perspectives from both sides of the international border as well as across languages.” Based on her presentation and reflecting on your own experiences, what are some benefits and challenges that may arise from navigating this kind of ‘translating’ work?
- According to the convocation introduction, “the general distrust of the media and its portrayals” seems to be an important piece of the context to Gonzalez’s work. Reflecting on your own experiences with civic engagement, particularly as it pertains to receiving and conveying information, what are some of your identities that become more salient and in what ways? What are the effects of that?
- In a ‘2020 News Reel’, Gonzalez demonstrates how she uses “data and creative storytelling” in various mediums, including cable news and videos, as an investigative reporter. How does using various communication tools and mediums honor diverse forms of knowledge? What kind of communications tools or mediums could you use in your civic engagement work that would create more shared knowledge and shared power?
- What did you learn about how the speaker’s individual life experience contributed to their academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does the speaker suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that the speaker envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Kao Kalia Yang (January 14, 2022)
Hmong-American writer, filmmaker, and teacher, Kao Kalia Yang delivered a convocation address on Friday January 14, 2022.
- In Carleton’s Voice 2008, Yang credits Carleton with giving her “the confidence to pursue writing. My professors taught me that the things I didn’t know, I could learn, and that the things I thought I knew, I could relearn.” Have you experienced “relearning” at Carleton either in the classroom or through civic engagement work? How has it shaped your interests and passions?
- Yang retells in an interview with Carleton’s Voice: “I read an excerpt from my book at a United Nations conference held at Columbia University and a woman from Eastern Europe stood up and said, ‘That’s my story,’ and another from Africa said the same thing. How can I not believe that I’m telling a fundamental human story?” Why is it important to find fundamental connections between your story and others? How might finding these connections strengthen relationships across difference?
- In Yang’s work Somewhere in the Unknown World, she tells the stories of fourteen refugee’s journeys. Yang describes her motivations for telling these stories “not because her subjects can’t speak for themselves. Rather, she offered her artistry to help them create a portrait they may not be able to see.” What is the importance of having your story be seen? What role does artistry play in honest storytelling?
- In Yang’s Ted Talk she mentions that her father’s hopes for his daughters in America were a “A future that I did not know how to envision, but words that I wanted to live in, and live in forever.” What kind of future do you desire but don’t know how to envision? Are there things (like words, art, or music) that give you hope that this future is possible?
- In this Hyphen blog post, Yang describes her and her uncle’s negative interview experience with NPR’s RadioLab podcast in 2012. Her public response to the interview includes that “there is a great imbalance of power at play… Robert Krulwich has the gall to say that I ‘monopolize’ – he who gets to ask the questions, has control over editing, and in the end: the final word. Only an imperialist white man can say that to a woman of color and call it objectivity or science.” How can journalism– interviewers, editors, and consumers– avoid power imbalances and promote the just sharing of stories?
- What did you learn about how Yang’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Yang suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Yang envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Tiya Miles (October 15, 2021)
- Miles’s convocation presentation is titled, “The Call of the Ancestors: Hope and the Historical Imagination.” What is historical imagination and how can it be used to create or sustain hope? How might you use historical imagination in your civic engagement work to create a more just future?
- The convocation introduction states that Miles’s work “explores the meeting place of public memory, urban history, African American, and American Indian history”. Based on her presentation, where do these four histories meet? Where do they diverge? What’s the benefit of considering different forms of knowledge or contradictory ways of thinking alongside each other?
- In this interview, Miles describes her experience on Ghost Tours in the Southern United States and discusses how the history of slavery in the South is often retold in problematic ways. Miles states that “there is the possibility of more serious engagement of Black history at these ghost tours, and that possibility can be realised depending upon the motivation of the tour guides, the heart of the tour guides, and also (most importantly) the material that is being used as the basis of these tours”. In your experience how has the motivation or “heart” of the narrator shaped how history is told and perceived? How does the material used shape the narrative of a particular history?
- In the same interview, Miles talks about a particular Ghost Tour centering the story of an enslaved woman named Molly. After deeper research she discovers that Molly’s story was entirely fabricated: “The story of Molly was created for commercial reasons, the story was attached to the development of the house as a tourist site”. How might money or power shape or alter how history is told? What tools can you use to critically engage with history and understand the motivation of storytellers?
- Miles’s work explores topics related to epistemic injustice, or “a wrong done to someone in their capacity as a knower.” Epistemic injustice can look like the “exclusion of marginalized and oppressed people from 1) being heard and understood by others in interpersonal communications, and 2) contributing to broader and deeper social understandings of the human experience.” What are some techniques you can use to repair the wrongs caused by epistemic injustice in the communities you are a part of? How might you equitably incorporate the knowledge and experiences of marginalized and oppressed people in your civic engagement work?
- What did you learn about how Miles’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Miles suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Miles envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Anton Treuer (October 9, 2021)
Ojibwe language educator, academic, and writer Anton Treuer will be delivering the convocation address on Friday, October 9.
- Treuer is a professor of Ojibwe at Bemidji State University, which is home to the first collegiate Ojibwe language program in the United States. What is the significance of teaching Ojibwe language in a college or university rather than in an informal community context or a k-12 setting? What are the limits and benefits of higher education as a site for language revitalization?
- In the opening section of his book, The Language Warrior’s Manifesto, Treuer reflects on his education, “I was sent to school for thirteen years, ostensibly to learn everything I needed to know to be successful in the world and none of it had anything to do with me.” (p.5) How could a monocultural curriculum cause harm? How does a culturally relevant curriculum fit into our land acknowledgement’s commitment to acts of healing and honest storytelling? In what ways has your educational experience centered or ignored aspects of your identity?
- Throughout his work, Treuer discusses how language loss happens and how to fight it. What are some practices you can implement in your civic-engagement work that can help fight language loss? How might that strengthen your work?
- In this interview, Treur refers to languages as, “unique bodies of knowledge that may contain some of the most critical solutions to the problems we face as humans.” And he likens the diversity of languages to a game of Jenga. “Every time we pull out a new language for extinction, we’ve destabilized the tower of human knowledge and problem-solving,” he said. What are some of the problems humans face that could be served by revitalizing marginalized languages? What solutions might exist in the expanse of languages spoken by humans?
- In an interview on the podcast Native Lights: Where Indigenous Voices Shine, Treurer states that “language reflects the values of a people but it also shapes the values of a people.” From what you’ve learned through Treuer’s presentation, what ways has language shaped Ojibwe values? How has your own language reflected or shaped you or your culture’s values?
- What did you learn about how Treuer’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Treuer suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Treuer envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Why Treaties Matter Exhibit (Fall 2021)
This fall, Carleton is hosting “Why Treaties Matter: Self-Government in the Dakota and Ojibwe Nations.” The exhibit, made in partnership between the Minnesota Humanities Center, the Minnesota Indian Affairs Council, and the Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian, explores relationships between Dakota and Ojibwe Indian Nations and the U.S. government in this place we now call Minnesota.
- What’s Carleton’s role in honoring treaties?
- How does the information displayed in this exhibit make you think differently about the place where you live and work?
- How do the concepts and perspectives in this exhibit build on or differ from those you’ve encountered in your prior learning?
Ayana Elizabeth Johnson (May 21, 2021)
Climate policy expert Ayana Elizabeth Johnson delivered a convocation address on Friday, May 21.
- Johnson works for both racial justice and climate justice. In this op-ed, she quotes Toni Morrison as saying, “the very serious function of racism … is distraction. It keeps you from doing your work. It keeps you explaining, over and over again, your reason for being.” In what ways could you consider racism a “distraction,” and what implications does this have for climate activism?
- Johnson’s convocation bio emphasizes aspects of her identity. The bio reads, “ Many of today’s most compelling climate leaders, across generations, are women—especially Black, Indigenous, and other women of color.” What significance does Johnson’s identity play in her role as an advocate and educator for climate work? How do aspects of your identity play a role in the community or civic work you take part in?
- In an interview with TIME, Johnson mentions that the issue with climate justice efforts is that the question isn’t “What we should do, ” but rather, “should we do anything?” What are some techniques we could use to move the conversation from “should” to “what” in the context of climate justice?
- In this interview about the launch of her podcast, How to Save a Planet, Johnson explains: “I really wish … people were thinking about, Okay, this is what I’m good at, and how does that match with the [climate justice] work that needs doing? It’s that sort of power mapping of your skills and network and resources that I wish people were thinking more about, instead of just, I guess I go to the next march.” Do you think that “power mapping” of one’s skills and resources is important to civic engagement and organizing? Have you ever purposefully employed this technique or a similar technique?
- Johnson responds in this interview that “those things [social justice and climate justice] are already intertwined, and when we try to deal with them separately, we set ourselves up for failure. If we try to just deal with climate or only deal with justice, then we’re dealing with a version of the problem that is so simplified as to be a problem that doesn’t actually exist.” What social justice issue(s) is your civic engagement work intertwined with? How does recognizing these connections change the work that you do?
- Johnson highlights an essay published in the anthology she co-edited, All We Can Save: “Leah Stokes’s essay … is about how to have ever broadening circles of influence as far as bringing about climate solutions. … She kind of leads people through how we get to the bigger and bigger changes that need to be made. And starting with yourself is certainly fine. But if it stops there, that will never be enough.” What circles of influence do you bring to your work in civic engagement? Does your work broaden your own circles or the circles of others?
- What did you learn about how Johnson’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Johnson suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Johnson envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Rachel Sumekh (May 14, 2021)
Social entrepreneur and founder of Swipe Out Hunger Rachel Sumekh delivered a convocation address on Friday, May 14, from 12:30 to 1:30 p.m.
- In this discussion about Swipe Out Hunger with UCLA students, Sumekh mentions that the best advice she received was from President Barack Obama: “many people are idealistic in their youth, and they say if you remain idealistic as you grow old then you’re crazy. But the truth is to stay idealistic as you grow old, otherwise we are not going to go anywhere new.” Why do you think this advice resonated so much with Sumekh and her mission? What place does idealism have in your work with civic engagement and drive to engage in this work?
- Sumekh made the 30 under 30 Forbes list in 2017. What is the significance of mainstream media recognition of a nonprofit entrepreneur? What does this say about the values praised by national media? What are the potential consequences of this type of attention and praise for activist movements?
- Swipe Out Hunger started with distributing meals from the dining halls to people in Skid Row, an LA neighborhood where there are high rates of impoverishment, as explained by Sumekh in this interview. What role did location play in the inspiration for and evolution of Swipe Out Hunger? What role do the priorities of your community play in your community or civic engagement, and what role should they play?
- On the Swipe out Hunger website the nonprofit asserts that their work strives to “advocate for legislation on a state and federal level to end student hunger” and that they “train students to become basic needs champions through their own advocacy efforts.” How do advocacy and volunteerism interact in community and civic engagement? What role do students play in developing what civic agency looks like? Why do you think this nonprofit emphasizes the role of students in civic engagement and advocacy?
- In this presentation Sumekh acknowledges, “there is no solution to hunger, it will always be a problem.” Instead, Swipe Out Hunger works toward creating attainable steps to reducing hunger in local communities. Do you agree that it is important to emphasize steps rather than a solution in addressing community needs? Why?
- In this op-ed, Sumakh writes about how her identity as a Persian Jewish woman has impacted her work, and the ways she seeks to challenge norms about who becomes involved in community work. What are the ways in which your identity impacts the community and civic work you have been a part of? What would you define as the norm in civic and community engagement? Would you like to revise or redefine that norm?
- What did you learn about how Sumekh’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Sumekh suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Sumekh envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Sia Her (May 7, 2021)
Hmong leader Sia Her delivered a convocation address on Friday, May 7, from 12:30 to 1:30 p.m.
- In her Minnesota Women’s Press featured profile, Her explains that there are “very few culturally and linguistically appropriate and responsive places for victims of abuse from the API [Asian and Pacific Islander] community to go to for the support they need.” Why is it important for places of support to be “culturally and linguistically appropriate and responsive?” What do you think would be required to make this change?
- In this profile, Her describes a disconnect: “We know anecdotally that Asian American women are experiencing violence at a high rate [in Minnesota]. What we don’t have is actual data.” What advantages does “actual data” have compared to anecdotal evidence? What barriers are there to obtaining “actual data,” and how can they be overcome?
- In response to the March 16 Atlanta shootings, Her asserts that “Acknowledging the context of this crime is crucial for processing it.” What types of contexts do you think Her is referring to? Why is it necessary to acknowledge these contexts to process events like the Atlanta shootings? How do you acknowledge context in your work with the community?
- In a joint letter advocating for the 2021 Increase Teachers of Color Act, Her stated that “while we all eagerly anticipate the end of the COVID-19 pandemic, the centuries-old pandemic of racial inequities will persist. This legislation takes meaningful action to resolve this legacy and offer opportunity to all students in Minnesota.” What does the use of the word “pandemic” contribute to Her and her co-author’s argument? What “pandemics” have you encountered in your work with the community, and what does this word choice suggest about how these issues should be addressed?
- Her serves as Executive Director for the Minnesota State Council on Asian Pacific Minnesotans. One of the goals of the Council, as per their website , is that “Minnesota’s API communities trust the Council. A key function of the Council is as a liaison between state government and Minnesota’s API communities, which requires mutual trust.” What is the significance of explicitly stating this as a goal for the Council? What role does mutual trust play in the relationships of your civic engagement?
- What did you learn about how Her’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Her suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Her envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Baz Dreisinger (April 30, 2021)
The author and founder of the Prison-to-College-Pipeline program at John Jay College of Criminal Justice delivered a convocation address on Friday, April 30.
- Dreisinger is the founder of a program that helps incarcerated people attend college called the “Prison-to-College Pipeline.” What is the impact of the word “pipeline” in the foundation’s name? Why is word choice important in naming organizations?
- In this video, Dreisinger states that justice is a complex term but that she defines it as a “push for humanity.” How is this similar to or different from definitions of justice you’re familiar with? If the criminal justice system defined justice the same way as Dreisinger does, what would change?
- This New York Times review of Dreisinger’s book, Incarceration Nations, quotes Dreisinger as arguing that “the world needs a healthy dose of Norwegian janteloven, ‘a condescending attitude toward individuality and personal success.’” Dreisinger goes on to say that “Janteloven has no room for mass incarceration.” Why do you think this would be the case? Do you think janteloven currently has a place in American culture, and do you think it should?
- Dreisinger explains that workers in the Norway prison system have “backgrounds in social work and law, while in the US it is run by people with military backgrounds.” How do you think this difference might play out in how the prison system functions in each country? What connections can you draw between this militaristic tendency in US prison operations and American culture more broadly?
- This New York Times review of Dreisinger’s book, Incarceration Nations, criticizes Dreisinger’s “insertion of herself into the narrative as a self-critical expert-naïf” as “distracting and occasionally overwrought.” What are some potential ethical risks Dreisinger’s book project runs? What is the role of narrative in social change, and what is the relationship between narrative and power?
- What did you learn about how Dreisinger’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Dreisinger suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Dreisinger envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Scott Freeman ’78 (April 16, 2021)
Environmental educator Scott Freeman ’78 delivered a convocation address on Friday, April 16.
- In this op-ed, Freeman argues against the conventional college lecture format: “Unfortunately, the data backing the use of lecture have almost always devolved to personal empiricism: ‘It worked for me.’ … faculty members aren’t representative of today’s learners, and data show that what worked for them does not work for the vast majority of their students.” In your own experience, have you ever noticed this type of “personal empiricism”? What are some ways to move the conversation in those contexts beyond “it worked for me”?
- Freeman asserts in this op-ed that “However well intentioned, statements and committees won’t solve the racism, equity and inclusion issues in our classrooms.” In fact, he calls such statements “the academic equivalent of ‘extending our thoughts and prayers.’” Do you agree with his comparison? How can colleges and universities move beyond this current method to enact meaningful change?
- In this study, Freeman and his fellow researchers found that after a single day of climate change education using local (rather than global) evidence, “students indicated (1) an increased awareness that global warming would affect their lives, (2) a greater willingness to change their personal behavior, and (3) a higher level of support for government action.” Does this finding surprise you? In your own education, which has been more emphasized, global or local contexts, and what do you think the effect has been?
- Freeman is both an environmentalist and an advocate for dismantling racist traditions in STEM classrooms, which he says include the traditional lecture format. In this essay, he emphasizes the importance of living “a natural life,” which he says is “characterized by an ecological state of mind, and by a humble and interdependent point of view.” How do you think living a “natural life” translates to the classroom as you’ve experienced it? What parallels can you see between Freeman’s life philosophy and his classroom advocacy?
- What did you learn about how Freeman’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Freeman suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Freeman envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Ralph James Savarese (April 2, 2021)
Disability studies scholar Ralph James Savarese will deliver a convocation address on Friday, April 2, from 12:30 to 1:30 p.m.
These questions are based on Savarese’s essay “From Neurodiversity to Neurocosmopolitanism: Beyond Mere Acceptance and Inclusion” (Chapter 11 of Herrera and Perry (eds.), Ethics and Neurodiversity, available online here) and also refer to the work of disability justice activist Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha.
- Throughout his essay, Savarese refers to individuals who are not on the autism spectrum or without any other forms of neurodiversity as “neurotypicals,” thereby specifically naming every group in the conversation about autism. Does this explicit naming of neurotypical people change the tone of the conversation? In your experience engaging with identities different from your own, has every group in the conversation been acknowledged? If not, what would change if they were?
- Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha comments that many abled people have been taught to think of the lived reality of many disabled people as “failure.” Where do you think the roots of this line of thinking lie? Is there a similar pattern of thinking regarding neurodiversity? How does this line of thinking intersect with how you personally think about failure?
- Savarese hopes for a “neurocosmopolitan mixing” of autism and neurotypicality, and starts to imagine what it would require. He specifies: “Both autism and neurotypicality must cease to be strictly themselves in the participatory presence of the other; the anthropologist on Mars must become, at least in part, a Martian.” When interacting with people with different backgrounds or identities from your own, have you seen yourself or others change due to the “participatory presence of the other”? What do you think the potential benefits or drawbacks might be to this shift?
- Savarse cites Melissa Park’s work in his proposals for a neurocosmopolitan future: “If respect is to flourish, it simply has to find a foothold in medicine where, as Melissa Park … puts it, ‘institutionalized forms of misrecognition are as debilitating as disease processes or diagnostic categories.”’ Although this example pertains to the field of medicine, have you encountered any “institutionalized forms of misrecognition” in your own life? If so, what could some possible solutions be?
- Piepzna-Samarasinha argues that “changing work to really embody disability justice means throwing out most ways people have learned how to organize.” Why do you think this might be the case, and by this reasoning, how does organizing need to change to embody disability justice? What needs to be thrown out? What needs to fill those empty spaces?
- What did you learn about how Savarese’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Savarse suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Savarese envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Sharon Washington Risher (February 12, 2021)
Minister and gun control activist Sharon Washington Risher delivered a convocation address on Friday, February 12, from 12:30 to 1: 30 p.m.
- Gun violence and gun control reforms are topics that are often hard to discuss in the United States. What aspects of U.S. history do you think contribute to this, and where in U.S. history can you identify the prospect of change?
- Risher is a reverend, and faith and forgiveness are central to her gun-control advocacy. How do you think these religious underpinnings affect the efficacy of her message, in either positive or negative ways? Generally speaking, does community organizing benefit from a shared identity? Why or why not?
- During Attorney-General William Barr’s confirmation, Risher testified: “As a member of the Everytown Survivor Network, I share my story to put a human face on our nation’s gun violence crisis.” Risher’s emphasis on a “human face” points to the importance of engendering empathy in effecting change. What is the role of empathy in activism, and what should it be? Are there any dangers or limits to using empathy as a tool?
- In her testimony at Attorney-General William Barr’s confirmation hearing, Risher named the nine individuals who were killed in the Charleston shooting so that her audience would “feel empowered to help bring about change.” How could you personally empower others to become involved in your community and bring about change, and what change would you seek to bring about?
- Risher is involved with the organization Everytown for Gun Safety, which describes itself as “a movement of nearly 6 million mayors, teachers, survivors, gun owners, students, and everyday Americans.” What messages does the wording of this statement send to its audiences? What could be its potential benefits and drawbacks?
- What did you learn about how Risher’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Risher suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Risher envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Bree Newsome (February 5, 2021)
Artist and civil rights activist Bree Newsome delivered a convocation address on Friday, February 5, from 12:30 to 1:30 p.m.
- Newsome asserts that protesting and voting are “both part of being a full citizen and participating in the society.” Do you agree or disagree, and why? What kinds of barriers could prevent people from participating fully in society?
- Newsome is known, among other things, for pulling down the Confederate flag at the South Carolina State House in 2015. She explains that she did so with “historical awareness,” which she describes as awareness of “the history of civil disobedience and the history of the civil rights movement in this country.” Is historical awareness necessary for activism? What kind of historical awareness do you have, and where does it come from—your background, your collegiate education, or another source?
- In this interview, Newsome reflects on her decision to remove the Confederate flag at the South Carolina State House, after which she was immediately arrested. Although she knew the act was dangerous, she says that “I knew that I would regret it more if I had an opportunity to do this—which I felt was very much the right thing to do—and we had not done it.” The flag in question has since been permanently removed, which she credits in part to her action. What is the relationship between civil disobedience and social change?
- Newsome explains the significance of her removal of a Confederate flag for herself personally: “I am a descendant of the people for whom this flag represented enslavement. … I just kind of remain humbled by it because it’s like, yes, it’s Bree Newsome scaling the flagpole but … it represents so much more than me.” In the same way that a Confederate flag is a symbol, Newsome recognizes that her act, as a Black woman, of removing the flag is also symbolic. What is the role of symbolism in cultural change, and how would you determine what constitutes a symbol?
- Newsome comments that “The things that Black women say become the talking points for politicians, but we don’t really have much political leverage beyond people calling for a kind of token representation from us in certain places or playing the role of mascot.” What constitutes political leverage? How is it determined who has political leverage and who doesn’t?
- What did you learn about how Newsome’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience, or vice versa?
- What skills or capacities does Newsome suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Newsome envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Dylan Miner (November 6, 2020)
Artist and art historian Dylan Miner delivered a convocation address on Friday, November 6.
- Miner argues that “when we think about contemporary art, we need to think of it as not always reproducing the dominant way of being in the world.” Do you agree that art either reproduces or counters the dominant way of being in the world? If so, is all art political? Why or why not?
- Activism has been extremely visible in the media and communities across the world throughout COVID-19. Existing movements against police brutality and structural racism have found new support and spaces, and new movements have also been created. Has art made similar strides during this time of pandemic, and how does this intersect with activism?
- Miner is quoted as saying, “We have to reclaim those small spaces, our stories, and use them to create [a] better and more just world.” What does it mean to reclaim a story, and how could it be used to create a better and more just world?
- Miner is described as “finding a wider audience as he moves from street art and Indigenous cultural centers to art galleries,” and has spoken about wanting to “engage with radical politics … within the confines of the museum or the gallery.” How might working with a museum or gallery change how an artist engages with radical politics? How might viewing an artwork in a gallery as opposed to on the street change how it is perceived, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
- Miner is quoted in this article as saying, “A lot of my work is about reclamation and understanding history. It’s not as something in the past … it’s understanding our own situatedness, our own being here in this time and space as integrally connected with history, but also understanding that history is not somehow removed from the future.” What do you think it means for an artist to understand their own situatedness? Do all artists understand this? How do you understand your own situatedness?
- What did you learn about how Miner’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Miner suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Miner envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Helen Forsythe (October 30, 2020)
Northfield activist and organizer Helen Forsythe delivered a convocation address on Friday, October 30.
- Forsythe is one of the founding members of Northfield Curbside Composting, which describes itself as “a locally run collection service with an emphasis on employing young people at living wage standards and empowering them through team decision making and management.” By benefiting both the community and the collective’s employees, this is an example of reciprocal community engagement. What criteria can we use to ensure that our projects are advantageous for both the organizers and the community when it might not always be clear?
- In what ways is youth activism unique? Consider what only youth can bring to the table, as well as any potential challenges of working with young people.
- Considering the ways in which Forsythe organizes youth activism and community engagement and the ways in which Carleton and its students organize activism and civic engagement, do Carleton students engage with their communities and activism in different ways than non–college students of similar ages?
- Forsythe started this gofundme page with the call to action “Help Minneapolis high school students in Young People’s Action Coalition replace police in our schools with real community alternatives and transform the education system towards racial justice!” The page has raised over $35,000 as of October 1st, 2020 for this cause. What are the advantages and limitations of platforms like gofundme as they apply to community organizing?
- In the age of social media, platforms like this gofundme page Forsythe created have the ability to be shared and to go viral. Are they a supplement or a substitution to traditional fundraising methods for community engagement organizations (or neither)?
- Forsythe is also a member of the Young People’s Action Coalition, which describes itself here as “a democratically run youth organization founded by students in 2013 to build an intersectional (social and environmental justice) youth movement in MN.” What place does intersectionality have in community involvement? What are the pros and cons of simultaneous activism in multiple areas?
- What did you learn about how Forsythe’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Forsythe suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Forsythe envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Ruth Wilson Gilmore (October 23, 2020)
Grassroots organizer and scholar Ruth Wilson Gilmore delivered a convocation address on Friday, October 23.
- In this interview, Gilmore explains that “abolition seeks to undo the way of thinking and doing things that sees prison and punishment as solutions for all kinds of social, economic, political, behavioral, and interpersonal problems. Abolition, though, is not simply decarceration—put everybody out on the street—it is reorganizing how we live our lives together in the world.” What is your relationship to the idea that punishment is a solution to social problems? How would we need to reorganize the way we live together in the world to truly dismantle this way of thinking?
- In the short documentary about Gilmore’s theories, Geographies of Racial Capitalism, Gilmore argues that “capitalism requires inequality and racism enshrines it.” How do you interpret the phrase “capitalism requires inequality”? Can it be applied to our current government, economy, and society in America? How does racism enshrine capitalism?
- COVID-19 is more prevalent in prison populations than in the general population. In this interview, Gilmore talks about the fact that “America has 1 in 4 prisoners in the world and 1 in 4 cases of COVID-19.” What are the potential implications of these two facts? What does this statistic suggest about the prison system or the systems that govern it?
- Critics of Gilmore contend that getting rid of the incarceration system would lead to disorganization. In this video interview, Gilmore addresses this concern, explaining that abolition “requires persistent organizing for what we need, organizing that’s already present in the efforts people cobble together to achieve access to schools, health care and housing, art and meaningful work, and freedom from violence and want.” What is the relationship between organization and disorganization as it is presented here? How do you see it play out in our present and our potential futures?
- Gilmore uses the term abolition interchangeably with ending the prison system. In the past, abolition has been used to refer to ending slavery in America. What do you think the significance of this terminology is? How does abolition extend to prisons? How would you define abolition based on Gilmore’s presentation?
- What did you learn about how Gilmore’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Gilmore suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Gilmore envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Additional reading: Gilmore recommends her recent works Abolition Geography and the Problem of Innocence and Beyond Bratton (p. 105, with Craig Gilmore).
Mindy Romero (October 16, 2020)
The political sociologist Mindy Romero delivered a convocation address on Friday, October 16.
- In this interview, Romero proposes a novel idea: integrating voting education into the American education system. What do you think Romero means by this, and what could be the impacts of such a program, on both voting and US politics in general? Do you think there would be political resistance to such a proposition, and why?
- Romero argues that the American education system should play a role in aiding voter turnout. What are some ways you can think of integrating voting into the education system?
- Romero is quoted in this article as predicting in 2020 “high turnout from young people in California and throughout the United States,” and saying that “because of the political context that we’re in … we’re seeing a lot of young people kind of galvanized, interested, following politics.” Do you agree with her prediction? What would you attribute this galvanization to?
- In these working papers, Romero and her fellow researchers found that, in early April 2020, a significant portion of the American population wanted to move to mail-in-ballots given the COVID-19 crisis. How would this change affect populations that are underrepresented in in-person voting, or people who are unfamiliar with voting by mail? Do you think public opinion has moved on this question since April, and why?
- In this interview with NBC, Romero discusses data that shows a dramatic increase in overall turnout in the 2018 midterm elections, as well as increases in the youth, Latinx, and Asian-American population turnouts. She asserts that this is partially or completely due to “homegrown mobilization efforts.” What do you think “homegrown mobilization efforts” look like, and how does this fit into the electoral process as you understand it?
- What did you learn about how Romero’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Romero suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Romero envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Kevin Escudero (October 13, 2020)
Brown University Assistant Professor Kevin Escudero delivered a guest lecture on Tuesday, October 13 from 4:30 to 5:30 p.m. The title of his presentation was “Organizing While Undocumented: Immigrant Youth’s Political Activism under the Law.”
- In this interview, Escudero describes the “legal and political barriers to organizing, namely the threat of deportation” that undocumented immigrant activists overcome in their social movement activism. Do you think these barriers have become more or less surmountable in the time of COVID-19, and why?
- In this Latinx Talk interview, Escudero conveys one of the main contexts in which his book functions: “given the fact that Latinx Studies and the broader fields of Ethnic Studies emerged from social movement struggle, this book underscores the continued importance of praxis, or connecting our scholarship to political action.” In your mind, how is scholarship connected to political action, and how should it be?
- Escudero has led several workshops with his students at the Providence Community Library. One of these workshops was a screening and discussion of Precious Knowledge, a 2011 documentary that follows the debate of whether Ethnic Studies should be taught at Tucson High School. Do you agree with the film’s tagline that Ethnic Studies are a “revolutionary education”? Are any of your courses at Carleton a “revolutionary education;” why or why not?
- What do you understand to be the challenges of organizing social movements among undocumented groups? Do Carleton social movements share any of these challenges?
- What did you learn about how Escudero’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Escudero suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Escudero envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Robin Wall Kimmerer (October 9, 2020)
Botanist Robin Wall Kimmerer delivered the Frank G. and Jean M. Chesley Lecture in Environmental Studies on Friday, October 9. The title of her presentation was “The Honorable Harvest: Indigenous Knowledge for Sustainability.”
Where not marked otherwise, these questions refer to Kimmerer’s essay “Learning the Grammar of Animacy,” which is found in her book Braiding Sweetgrass and available online through the Gould Library.
- In the essay “A Mother’s Work,” Kimmerer says, “The pond built my muscles, wove my baskets, mulched my garden, made my tea, and trellised my morning glories. Our lives became entwined in ways both material and spiritual. It’s been a balanced exchange: I worked on the pond and the pond worked on me, and together we made a good home.” How can we apply this account of reciprocity with nature to our relationships with community partners?
- Kimmerer says that “to be native to a place we must learn to speak its language,” and calls the sounds of nature her first language, after her mother’s heartbeat. According to Kimmerer, what is the difference between hearing the sounds of “the shhh of wind in needles, water trickling over rock,” and speaking the language of that place?
- Kimmerer talks about the need to “be bilingual between the lexicon of science and the grammar of animacy.” What assumptions do you think each of these languages might contain, and how might they be in conflict?
- The English language, Kimmerer says, “doesn’t give us many tools for incorporating respect for animacy. In English, you are either a human or a thing.” Kimmerer makes this point in the context of describing plants and animals, but how do you think this feature of the English language might connect to England’s history of colonization?
- Kimmerer explains how using the pronoun “it” for animate beings like plants encourages us to see ourselves as separate and superior, and helps us justify our destruction of the natural world. In this article, she suggests we adopt the pronoun “ki” instead. How do you think our language conventions shape how we view and treat the world? What is our responsibility to the world in how we use language?
- What did you learn about how Kimmerer’s individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Kimmerer suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Kimmerer envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Alexander Heffner (October 2, 2020)
The journalist Alexander Heffner delivered a convocation address on Friday, October 2. The title of his presentation was “Civil Discourse in an Uncivil Age: The Quest for a Post-Partisan Citizenship.”
- Mr. Heffner’s work focuses substantially on the roles of social media and technology in civil discussion. How have these roles changed in recent years and in the time of COVID-19, and how has civil discussion changed as a result?
- Heffner has spoken at length about how the age of virality has altered how information is produced and consumed. In 2020, anyone can create content, but only a small portion of this content reaches the general population, often due to how many times it is shared and reposted. What responsibility do we as individuals and as a community have to make sure that we are engaging with and contributing to reputable content from a variety of viewpoints? How, practically, can we do so?
- In this March 2016 interview, Heffner talks about how democracy has moved online and how the steps to involve young people in democracy have changed, such as the best ways to communicate with young people and the ideas young voters are passionate about. Are these issues still relevant today? Have they become more or less relevant in the past four years?
- Consider Heffner’s main platform, The Open Mind, which has been called [a] radical approach to TV talk because of its focus on low-key, in-depth conversations. Why would this be considered radical, and what are the pros and cons of this approach?
- In this September 2020 interview, Heffner talks with University of Washington biologist Carl Bergstrom about how data has become politicized. How can data be politically convenient or inconvenient? How can scientists, politicians, and news consumers work together to maintain the integrity of data?
- In the globalization of the 20th and 21st centuries, and in the time of COVID, does any country’s civil discourse and political atmosphere stay contained within national borders?
- What did you learn about how Heffner’s individual life experience contributed to his academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Heffner suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Heffner envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?
Stacey Abrams (September 14, 2020)
The political leader, nonprofit CEO, and author Stacey Abrams delivered the opening convocation address on September 14.
- Abrams is a very intentional communicator across lines of difference. What tactics does she use, and how effective are they?
- How does Abrams respond to the polarization of political discourse in the United States? Does she seek to perpetuate or remedy it?
- In this profile, Abrams suggests that the political polarization in the United States is an effect of media polarization. What lessons can be taken from her convocation address about how citizens should respond to each of these issues?
- In this profile, published in May 2019, Abrams suggests reparations for African Americans and Native Americans is becoming a more credible possibility because people are now willing to have conversations about it. What does this suggest about the role community action plays in public discourse, and how do you think this discourse has changed in the past year?
- In this interview, Abrams describes how, since 2013, when the Supreme Court struck down key provisions of the Voting Rights Act, access to voting has been increasingly restricted, particularly among poor communities and communities of color, and that voter suppression works both by blocking access and by making people feel defeated. Abrams started Fair Fight to help combat this. What progress has Fair Fight made, and what are its limits?
- What did you learn about how Abrams’ individual life experience contributed to her academic learning experience?
- What skills or capacities does Abrams suggest are needed to create a more just society? Do you share any of those skills or capacities?
- What is the desired future that Abrams envisions? In what ways is it similar or different to the future you envision?